What Judith Marcuse Said

BC Artists Coalition

Scotiabank Dance Centre

September 27, 2010

Introduction by Judith Marcuse

Welcome. This meeting has been called to get us caught up with each other and to do some creative advocacy work together.

I’m delighted to recognize the wealth of perspectives and knowledge we have here all in one room. I am very hopeful that our different individual and collective ideas will enable us to move forward on the many fronts of our concerns about arts and culture in BC. And that this gathering will provide energy and action for positive change, both in the short term and into the future.

It’s just over a year ago that the BC government made the unprecedented, surreal and illogical cuts to investment in our 78,000-person-strong sector. Over the course of the year there have been some victories as a result of the extraordinary advocacy work that has taken place.

Indulge me here as I acknowledge and celebrate some of that work…in no particular order. The 10,000 letters that have been sent to politicians and others from BC citizens and from across Canada; the rallies, the dances, the Grey Square relay, the Solidarity photo project of miners, loggers, farmers holding signs supporting the arts; the postcards and the videos; the petitions; the hundreds of speeches at arts events across the province; the many press releases and media campaigns that got wide-ranging public coverage, local, national and online; the meetings with ministers and other government representatives; the presentations to the BC Budget Finance Committee, the toolkits provided by the Arts Alliance, now also being used by the informal coalition of BC arts service organizations that the Alliance is facilitating;.the publishers, music associations, touring council;—the list is here if you want to see it—the celebrity statements; the statistics and other data assiduously gathered to clarify confusing information from the government; the hiring of a lobbyist paid for by a coalition in Victoria and some of the large Lower Mainland arts organizations with the Alliance which has contributed thousands of hours of staff time; the resignation of the chair of the BCAC, Jane Danzo; the launch of new websites that are providing up-to-the minute news on the advocacy front; the promise by the Minister of a Day at the Legislature; the Alliance’s work to co-ordinate meetings with every MLA in the province. The ongoing initiatives of the Grey Square, PAARC, Stop BC Arts Cuts; the Alliance, the Assembly of BC Arts Councils, the lobbyist, Mark Marissen; and Arts Advocacy BC, which has a pan-provincial mandate. And many other initiatives. The list goes on and on. So many new conversations with new contacts, honing our positions and the languages with which to present them.

We have some short term and possibly-sustainable victories to celebrate. We now have a public commitment from the present government at least NOW, to the principle of arms-length investment in arts and culture, a critical position that we must be vigilant to ensure is imbedded both in the short term and in the provincial policy we hope to see created one day soon.

Some of the cuts were restored: $7 million was restored to the BC Arts Council and the outcry overthe Spirit Festivals changed some of the policy surrounding that program, but we have a long way to go. Many of you will know that some of the arts funding stats—nearly $40 per person in Saskatchewan, more than $20 in Alberta, for example, and  in BC $6.45. Triple the BC budget, and we’re still at the bottom. There are serious inequalities between the various regions of the province, as well .

There are serious problems with the Embrace BC program which many arts groups are trying access. These.include issues of intellectual property rights. The Gaming situation, of core concern to many of us, is a morass of confusion.

We have begun to come to together as a community to recognize our strengths and our allies, our audiences, our boards, our children, educators, other civil society organizations, citizen groups, chambers of commerce, businesses, health and justice system individuals and organizations, and we are connecting in new ways with the private sector, which in fact, in Canada, outstrips the public sector in its investment in arts and culture. (We must reposition the words…not grants or subsidies. )

There will be an election in a few years and work toward that is much longer-term, but here are the starting point goals that the planning committee offers to you.

Goals:

1.      Increased and stable investment in our sector (e.g. three-year BCAC support programs like Canada Council). To include funding for operating, projects and individuals. A tripling of pre-cut levels, still would be lowest in Canada.

2.      Guarantee of arms-length funding policy as part of the creation of an overall arts policy for the province

3.      Restoration of clear access to Gaming revenues

4.      Re-establishment of intellectual property rights specific to Embrace BC new rules

5.      More equitable policies and actions for artists and organizations in rural areas of the province

[Judith then went on to describe the break-out groups which were to follow and report at the meeting’s conclusion.]

Last week I wrote a blog post that was picked up by the Georgia Straight where I shared my views of the Spirit Festival grant program.

Thanks to all who responded, commented (60+), Retweeted (60+) and “liked” on Facebook (700+).

Here is a sample of some of the comments people made. The positive comments far out numbered the negative comments. In fact, there was really only one negative commenter who left a few comments.

POSITIVE COMMENTS

Bravo! You’ve said what surely everyone is thinking.

Hear hear!

Thanks for speaking up. I agree with you completely.

Starting a festival just to access a grant is the same as buying a rope to hang yourself with.

Another brilliant, articulate and bang on assessment from John McLachlan.

Brilliant & great incite from the voice of experience. Thank You John.

Thank you John. You said it.

Few festivals thrive in February (other than maybe the Push Festival — which is brilliant) — but BC spirit festivals?? They’re kidding, right? They aren’t? Oh my freaking god.

Thanks you John! we don’t need spirit festivals, or retractable roofs or whatever. Its just a little too ‘art for the state’ flavoured for this jew…..

Thanks, John. Too bad we can’t draft you onto the BC Arts Council. The gagged silence from those who are supposed to be the custodians of culture in BC is deafening.

Amen, John. This is without doubt the worst example of incompetent mismanagement of the cultural sector in Canadian history. The BC Arts Council does need to take a very strong public stand now, but the real villains are Minister Krueger and Premier Campbell whose unprecedented political interference in the cultural life of this province makes us the laughingstock of the whole country. The only artistic production in this province that needs its funding cut is Liberals du Soleil.

Well said and thank you, John McLachlan. These Spirit of BC festivals grants for artistic propaganda promoting the BC so-called So-Cred-Liberal government on the backs of struggling arts organizations sound suspiciously like Leni Riefenstahl’s work for Hitler’s Germany. Let’s remember that artists like Kurt Weill, Bertolt Brecht, George Grosz, Kurt Schwitters, Otto Dix and others left Nazi Germany. Can BC afford this kind of exodus because it’s already begun – Crystal Pite, Kika Thorne, Cheyanne Turions and others. Elaine Carol, Artistic Director, MISCELLANEOUS Productions

This has Campbell written all over it. He’s just looking for another expensive party for his rich friends and a chance to wave his fucking red mitts in the air. There’s sea of drunks on Granville street already and it’s free! Give the money BACK to the real arts.

Agreed!

BC Spirit festival? The spirit of fascism, is being celebrated, attempting to thwart the spirit of artistic creation? pulling funding from that which goes against their corporate business like ideological spirit..? thats what this is about. Cant wait for these pigs to wake up to a complete rejection by the citizens of BC. sooner than their 3 year nondate. I can say I never once darkened the door of any BORELYMPIC festival during those horrible 2 weeks.

Well said. Haven’t business types always assumed that the art community lacks acumen of any kind? Are they trickling some scraps our way to appease us? Please, we must not re-elect them.

This program is worse than those stupid Millennium grants. How many arts organizations and artists were looking for ways to celebrate the Millennium? The quintessential top-down policy.

In this case, how many arts organizations in the north want to hold festivals in February? Another fine business model from the supposedly fiscally-prudent govt.

I can’t wait for winter with hordes of people driving to Wells from the Lower Mainland and Victoria in their all-season tires

How about a Spirit of BC Rail Festival? We could set up model trains all over BC and then sell them to the highest bidder – after a few insider shenanigans!

Or a Spirit of PST Festival? Set up yard sales & kiosks and charge the good ol’ pre-HST %.

No doubt there are many Spirits lurking in the wings that would make excellent themes. Otherwise, I hope every arts group boycotts this nonsense.

These ‘Spirit Festival’ organizers should have taken a look at Calgary’s desperate attempts to keep their ‘Olympic Spirt’ on life support after the 1988 Games. There’s a reason why you’ve never heard of the Calgary Winter Festival.

It’s like the people who won’t take their Xmas decorations down until well into February – give it up and move on already.

Well said, John. Thanks for the straight talk.

We need the BC government to restore arms-length funding of culture and art, and stop bleeding real artists and cultural organizations dry!

Diverting funds from real art to a blatant propaganda event is reprehensible behavior and indicates no respect or understanding of what art or culture is. Real art and culture creates a real legacy.

John, In complete agreement with your thoughts on this issue. It’s really disheartening to see the BCAC on life support and the adverse affect the radical funding cuts are having on the provincial arts sector. Spirit Festival concept is complete rubbish designed to buy votes in non urban communities and simultaneously to tell the “real cultural workers” in the community exactly what they (Liberal gov’t) think of them. The gov’t just doesn’t give a damn about culture and art. That much seems pretty clear.

Totally agree. Everyone I talk to think that the idea of ‘Spirit Festivals’ is really tacky.

Is there any chance that the government will back down on this ill-conceived and incredibly gauche idea? Is this REALLY going to happen? Maybe it’s a government conspiracy…they’re hoping that all the arts orgs will be so upset that everyone will boycott, so they can shrug ‘your loss’ and put the money back in their pockets ?

Given the unanimous opposition to the BC Spirit Festival expressed here, will artists take the next step and boycott it?

Artists and concerned citizens can complain all they want – but what does any of it mean if grant applications continue to be submitted?

If you hate what the government is doing to the arts – if you hate this festival in particular – you have to unite and, in solidarity, declare you will have nothing to do with it.

Boycott the BC Spirit Festival.

Consider this folks – the ‘Spirit Festival’ grant can only be applied for by Members of the Assembly of BC Arts Councils, or Aboriginal Friendship Centres, Band Councils or other Aboriginal cultural organizations.

Too bad they didn’t resurrect the BC Festival of the Arts. Every year a different city took it on, it supported all manner of art and artists, all at the same time. It was uplifting to be present at one whether or not you were a delegate.

And February? A bad storm and there go your participants

Right on John. I was wondering when someone would speak the truth about this ridiculous idea. 30 million thrown away while bonafide groups, like mine, the Vancouver Philharmonic Orchestra, limp along after 100% cuts. It;s sheer insanity.These Liberals wouldn’t know art from a f-art. These are scary times for democracy and the arts, two things that go hand in hand.

Right on!!! Thanks for speaking up when so many of us feel we can’t . Millions of dollars being sucked up by/for the Olympic Games…AGAIN, instead of being used for and by the community at large. It would be laughable if not so devastating.

BRAVO!

Well put, John. And yes, shameless hussy productions will boycott this BC Spirit Festival grant crap. Why not go out in flames?!

Boycott the Spirit Festival!

I applaud John McLachlan and Jane Danzo for standing up and telling everyone that what the Campbell Liberals are doing to the Arts in BC is unacceptable. They give us something to cheer for but unless we stand with them and form a united artistic protest we lack a strong enough voice. If we apply for these Spirit Grants and implement the government’s vision of what artists should do, we sell out our own community and our own visions. Let’s do what artists do best – show people what is and what is possible!

This is bang on. The only art gallery in my northern B.C. town lost all it’s funding from the province and is now fundraising locally in order to keep its doors open so that local artists have a place to show their work. It’s sad times and a festival celebrating last year’s news isn’t new or innovative.

I did NOT vote for this. Stop killing the Arts.

Oh yeah, Spirit Festivals. Those are those parades Kim Jong Il throws, right?

Sorry but if you had worked in industry and business as I have for many years, you’d be well aware of the handouts given to that sector not involved in the arts (Sun-Rype, mining companies, lumber, and the list goes on and on)!

The more restrictions you put on arts-based funding, the less art that gets made…. so, are we all to assume that this province, and this country are becoming too elitist for the majority of the citizens to actually live here?!

The cultural crème de la crème are replying to you Mr. Campbell and Mr. Krueger in these comments in support of John’s position. And we are only the tip of the iceberg.

When are each and every one of us finally going to take back the power into our own hands and start demanding that this government remember that we are their employers and we pay their salary and we have the power to fire them? Now that’s a festival I could get behind!!!

We must address public mistrust of government funding of the arts. We are a province of people who don’t get the business, jobs, and value impact culture plays in our quality of life and our prosperity as a province. Perhaps it’s from too long and so recently being solely reliant on resource based industries.

Providing seed money to the arts is economic stimulus and is the lifeblood of our ability to fully join the knowledge based economy, fight the brain drain, and lure central business activity like head offices to BC

NEGATIVE COMMENT

If the arts community cannot sustain itself as opposed to perpetual reliance on the taxpayer for funding, then it has no reason to exist.

The arts community faces a huge challenge in British Columbia and its relationship to public funding. How do we change our situation from the mess we are in where the Minister feels we are “vicious” and the public doesn’t even know there’s an issue at stake.

The traditional view of where economic value comes from in this province needs to be updated. The population is still stuck thinking it’s only from resources, tourism, and good public sector jobs. Though it’s true, this accounts for a huge amount, the general public just doesn’t really get how much cultural economic activity exists and how much it adds to our economy.

Money is just one half the battle. In fact, it’s often said that making the economic argument is the weakest approach. The other half is that we need to show the value of supporting arts and how it filters through to making the lives of people better in so many ways. The general public (voters) don’t see this now.

The public’s worldview just doesn’t include the value of arts either economically or socially. Until that changes, we are stuck in our ghetto.

We have our work cut out for us. And it will be hard because we are a varied group of people working in many different areas of the arts.

We don’t have a natural way to be united as one and that is what works against us. The BC Arts Council could be the way, but in its current state, it can’t be because it has no power or authority.

Somehow, we need an organization with a strong leader to come forward and do two things: Lead and Organize. I don’t know who that is. It is not the Assembly of BC Arts Councils as its mandate is too closed and it’s now dealing with giving out grants. It could be the Alliance for Arts and Culture, but its mandate is strictly Metro Vancouver and if its mandate were to change it would make those “not in Vancouver” nervous.

We need an organization and a person who wants to lead.

We need someone who we can rally around who has the guts to stand up and be noticed and who can take the message to the people in an effective and clear way. If a person or organization showed this in any way, I’d donate time and money to help.

We need to put forward the reason for arts funding support like a marketer would by understanding who we are selling to and moving the needle of support where it’s possible to be moved and ignoring it where it’s not.

It would be a huge undertaking.

Who? Where? What? When? How?

Am I completely off-base or dreaming? What are you thoughts?

DO SOMETHING DIFFERENT

DO SOMETHING DIFFERENT

If what you’re doing isn’t working, do something different. If you find yourself in a hole, stop digging.

Sound advice which the arts community does not seem to be heeding.

Yesterday, I asked a random dozen or so people if they knew who Jane Danzo was. No one had heard of her. So much for the dramatic resignation!

Then David Diamond (Headlines Theatre) spoke, on the CBC’s Early Edition, in definitive terms. That is, he did not appeal, in polite terms, to government generosity.

Now, I fear that will be the end of it.

David also said that his colleagues in the arts community had advised him not to speak out.

What are we afraid of?

A number of years ago, I proposed the formation of a provincial union of artists and arts groups to create a powerful lobby and an articulate and passionate public voice. The response was, “Oh, that sounds too much like biting the hand that feeds us.” You can see where the.cautious and humble approach has gotten us.

What are you doing that is different?

Unless we were to have an enlightened government that would take a leadership role in the arts, we will see the continued erosion of support for the arts. And I believe it’s safe to say that private and corporation philanthropy will take its cues from government. Change can only happen when the arts become an election issue. That means taking risks. That means engaging the public—all those people who never heard of Jane Danzo, or David Diamond, for that matter.

So far, there have been mild protests, extensive letter and postcard campaigns addressed to government, and two people who have spoken out. No wonder arts advocates are looked at as a “special interest group.” We’re preaching to the converted and to the unconvertible.

What are you going to do to make a difference?

Last week, the Chair of the BC Arts Council, Jane Danzo, resigned stating that it was her best way of advocating for change and to show her displeasure with the way the BC Arts Council is required to operate by the Government.

See letter here

I don’t know Jane and I don’t know all the machinery at the BC Arts Council so I could be completely “off” on what I am about to say, but here goes.

Many in the arts community seems to be applauding Ms. Danzo for her bold and courageous move (see Alliance for Arts and Culture’s response ) and I join them in saying it’s great to hear her reasons and frustrations but…

It seems to me that if she’d spoken her mind while she still held the position and made the Government very uncomfortable, they would have fired her which would have had a much bigger impact than the footnote articles the story is now getting in the media.

The move would have made the Government look bad (which they are). We are left now with one more person (soldier in the battle for arts funding) like the rest of us, on the outside but with no explosive impact.

My challenge to the rest of the BC Arts Council board? SPEAK OUT NOW before your term is up or you decide to resign.

Make the Government very uncomfortable.

Get removed.

At least it will have some impact.

Arts Think Tank Anyone?

Maybe we need to develop an Arts Advocacy Think Tank that is similar in structure to the Fraser Institute and over time, slowly develop “research” and become an authoritative voice on arts that government will listen to.

Just a thought.

Check out this Tyee article about the Fraser Institute.

I came across this very interesting study about effective advocacy. I know it’s a fairly long read–complete with charts and tables–but it’s worth taking the trouble to download and read. This link will get you there:

What Makes an Effective Advocacy Organization

“This analysis and framework can be useful to any kind of organization interested in increasing its effectiveness related to advocacy…”

One point that I found especially resonant is the importance they place on leadership.  Where is the leadership we need to advocate for the arts–with the public as well as with government? In fact, why should government pay any attention to our voices unless we have the support and following of a large public. I am reminded again of the environment movement.

Where is our David Suzuki?

Tagged with:
© 2010 Arts Advocacy BC